Smoked Gouda Jalapeño New York Strip finished and ready to serve

Smoked Gouda Jalapeño New York Strip

Save, rate, and make it yours

Optional account features. You can still read every recipe without logging in.

Your rating
Quick Answer

Smoked Gouda Jalapeño New York Strip tops seared strip steaks with a melty compound butter of smoked Gouda, roasted jalapeño, and scallion.

Jump to Recipe

Smoked Gouda melts into a nutty, campfire-scented richness, and roasted jalapeño brings gentle heat without the raw bite. Together in a compound butter over a seared strip steak, they taste like the best parts of a loaded steakhouse special.

Roasting the jalapeño first softens its edge and adds a little smoke of its own. Mix the butter, sear the strips, and let a spoonful melt over the top — it's a five-minute upgrade that eats like a much bigger effort.

Prep15 minutes
Cook20 minutes
Total35 minutes
Serves2 servings
DifficultyMedium

Ingredients

  • 2 New York strip steaks, 12–14 ounces each
  • 1½ teaspoons kosher salt
  • ¾ teaspoon black pepper
  • 1 tablespoon neutral oil
  • 3 tablespoons unsalted butter, softened
  • ⅓ cup finely grated smoked Gouda
  • 1 roasted jalapeño, seeded and minced
  • 1 small garlic clove, grated
  • 1 tablespoon sliced scallions

Instructions

  1. 1Mix the butter, smoked Gouda, jalapeño, garlic, and scallions.
  2. 2Season the steaks with salt and pepper.
  3. 3Sear in a hot oiled skillet for 3–4 minutes per side.
  4. 4Continue cooking until 125–135°F.
  5. 5Rest for 8 minutes and top with the Gouda jalapeño butter.

Pro Tips

  • Roast the jalapeño before mincing it — it tames the raw heat and adds a subtle smoky depth that raw pepper can't.
  • Grate the Gouda finely so it melts smoothly into the butter instead of forming stubborn clumps.
  • Chill the compound butter until firm so it melts slowly over the hot steak instead of running straight off.

Substitutions

smoked Gouda → smoked cheddar or regular Gouda Smoked cheddar is sharper; plain Gouda loses the smoke but stays creamy.
jalapeño → roasted poblano for less heat or serrano for more Roast whichever you choose; the smoke matters as much as the heat.
New York strip → ribeye or sirloin Ribeye is richer; sirloin is leaner, so pull it a few degrees early.

Storage Instructions

Store leftover steak in the refrigerator for up to 3 days and keep extra Gouda butter wrapped for up to a week. Reheat the steak gently.

Make Ahead

The smoked Gouda jalapeño butter can be made ahead and refrigerated for a week or frozen as a log. Sear the steaks fresh.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I make Smoked Gouda Jalapeño New York Strip ahead of time?

The smoked Gouda jalapeño butter can be made ahead and refrigerated for a week or frozen as a log. Sear the steaks fresh.

How do I store leftover Smoked Gouda Jalapeño New York Strip?

Store leftover steak in the refrigerator for up to 3 days and keep extra Gouda butter wrapped for up to a week. Reheat the steak gently.

Can I freeze Smoked Gouda Jalapeño New York Strip?

The compound butter freezes for up to 2 months. Cooked strip steak is best fresh but can be frozen if needed.

What should I serve with Smoked Gouda Jalapeño New York Strip?

A loaded baked potato, elote-style corn, or crispy potatoes lean into the smoky-spicy theme. A cold lager cuts the richness perfectly.

Can I adjust Smoked Gouda Jalapeño New York Strip for the ingredients I actually have?

Yes. The Substitutions section on this page covers the swaps that actually hold up. Keep the sear-and-rest order the same and you have room to adjust the flavors around it.

What is the most common mistake when making Smoked Gouda Jalapeño New York Strip?

Roast the jalapeño before mincing it — it tames the raw heat and adds a subtle smoky depth that raw pepper can't.

How long does Smoked Gouda Jalapeño New York Strip take?

About 35 minutes from start to finish, including 20 minutes of active cooking. Most of it is hands-on, so plan to stay near the stove.

You Might Also Like

Za’atar Brown Butter Ribeye Za’atar Brown Butter Ribeye Roasted Red Pepper Romesco Filet Mignon Roasted Red Pepper Romesco Filet Mignon Pickled Cherry Bourbon Cowboy Ribeye Pickled Cherry Bourbon Cowboy Ribeye Truffle Soy New York Strip with Crispy Garlic Truffle Soy New York Strip with Crispy Garlic Blackberry Bourbon Ribeye with Cracked Pepper Blackberry Bourbon Ribeye with Cracked Pepper Miso Pecan Butter New York Strip Miso Pecan Butter New York Strip

Finish With Dessert

Cinnamon Rolls Recipe: Soft, Gooey, Glazed All the Way Through

Try this next

Cinnamon Rolls Recipe: Soft, Gooey, Glazed All the Way Through

View recipe →