Molasses Mustard New York Strip finished and ready to serve

Molasses Mustard New York Strip

Save, rate, and make it yours

Optional account features. You can still read every recipe without logging in.

Your rating
Quick Answer

Molasses Mustard New York Strip glazes seared strip steaks with a tangy-sweet blend of molasses, whole-grain mustard, and cider vinegar.

Jump to Recipe

This is a Southern pantry glaze at heart — molasses or sorghum syrup for deep, dark sweetness, whole-grain mustard for tang and texture, and cider vinegar to keep it lively. Brushed onto a seared strip steak, it caramelizes into a sticky, savory lacquer.

It's a fast, no-fuss weeknight move that leans on ingredients you probably already have. Mix the glaze in a bowl, sear the steaks, then brush and finish. Keep a little glaze back to spoon over at the table.

Prep10 minutes
Cook20 minutes
Total30 minutes
Serves2 servings
DifficultyEasy

Ingredients

  • 2 New York strip steaks, 12–14 ounces each
  • 1½ teaspoons kosher salt
  • ¾ teaspoon black pepper
  • 1 tablespoon neutral oil
  • 2 tablespoons sorghum syrup or dark molasses
  • 1½ tablespoons whole-grain mustard
  • 1 tablespoon apple cider vinegar
  • 1 garlic clove, finely grated
  • 1 teaspoon Worcestershire sauce

Instructions

  1. 1Mix the molasses, mustard, vinegar, garlic, and Worcestershire.
  2. 2Season the steaks with salt and pepper.
  3. 3Sear in a hot oiled skillet for 3–4 minutes per side.
  4. 4Brush with the glaze and cook for 1–2 minutes more per side, until 125–135°F.
  5. 5Rest for 8 minutes and serve with any remaining glaze.

Pro Tips

  • Brush the glaze on only in the final minutes. Molasses is high in sugar and will burn if it cooks too long over high heat.
  • Grate the garlic finely so it melts into the glaze instead of scorching in raw chunks on the steak.
  • Reserve a spoonful of glaze before it touches the raw steak so you have a clean drizzle for serving.

Substitutions

sorghum syrup → dark molasses or pure maple syrup Molasses is deeper and slightly bitter; maple is milder and cleaner.
whole-grain mustard → Dijon or yellow mustard Dijon is smoother and sharper; whole-grain adds the seedy texture.
New York strip → ribeye or flat iron Any steak takes the glaze well; adjust cook time to the cut.

Storage Instructions

Store leftover steak in the refrigerator for up to 3 days with the glaze alongside. Reheat gently and brush with reserved glaze to freshen it.

Make Ahead

The molasses mustard glaze can be mixed days ahead and refrigerated. Sear the steaks fresh and glaze at the end.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I make Molasses Mustard New York Strip ahead of time?

The molasses mustard glaze can be mixed days ahead and refrigerated. Sear the steaks fresh and glaze at the end.

How do I store leftover Molasses Mustard New York Strip?

Store leftover steak in the refrigerator for up to 3 days with the glaze alongside. Reheat gently and brush with reserved glaze to freshen it.

Can I freeze Molasses Mustard New York Strip?

The glaze keeps well frozen for up to 2 months. Cooked strip steak is best fresh but can be frozen if needed.

What should I serve with Molasses Mustard New York Strip?

Collard greens, cornbread, or a skillet of creamed corn lean into the Southern theme. A cold beer or sweet tea keeps it casual.

Can I adjust Molasses Mustard New York Strip for the ingredients I actually have?

Yes. The Substitutions section on this page covers the swaps that actually hold up. Keep the sear-and-rest order the same and you have room to adjust the flavors around it.

What is the most common mistake when making Molasses Mustard New York Strip?

Brush the glaze on only in the final minutes. Molasses is high in sugar and will burn if it cooks too long over high heat.

How long does Molasses Mustard New York Strip take?

About 30 minutes from start to finish, including 20 minutes of active cooking. Most of it is hands-on, so plan to stay near the stove.

You Might Also Like

Preserved Lemon Pistachio Ribeye Preserved Lemon Pistachio Ribeye Port Wine Plum Filet Mignon Port Wine Plum Filet Mignon Smoked Gouda Jalapeño New York Strip Smoked Gouda Jalapeño New York Strip Za’atar Brown Butter Ribeye Za’atar Brown Butter Ribeye Roasted Red Pepper Romesco Filet Mignon Roasted Red Pepper Romesco Filet Mignon Pickled Cherry Bourbon Cowboy Ribeye Pickled Cherry Bourbon Cowboy Ribeye

Finish With Dessert

Cinnamon Rolls Recipe: Soft, Gooey, Glazed All the Way Through

Try this next

Cinnamon Rolls Recipe: Soft, Gooey, Glazed All the Way Through

View recipe →